[ruby-talk:11447] Re: Array bugs?

>>>>> "C" == Christoph Rippel <[e-mail]> writes:
>> From: ts [mailto:[e-mail]]
>> >>>>> "M" == Mathieu Bouchard <[e-mail]> writes:

 I'll try to explain what do ruby actually

M> def f(x); [x,x]; end
M> def g(x); f f f f f f f f x; end
M> (g g g 1) == (g g g 1) #=> true

 In this case it do something like this :
   
   class Array
      def ==(other)
         each_index do |i|
            return false if not self[i] == other[i]
         end
         true
      end
   end


 This explain why it has problem with recursive array.

>> 
>> def f(x); [x,x]; end
>> def g(x); f f f f f f f f x; end
>> p (g g g 1)

 In this case inspect is protected, and ruby do (this is *very* simplified) 

   class Array
      def inspect
         return '[]' if empty?
         return '[...]' if @inspect.include? id
         begin
            @inspect.push id
            str = '['
            each do |i|
               str << i.inspect
            end
	    str << ']'
         ensure
            @inspect.pop
         end
         str
      end
   end

 where @inspect is in reality a thread local variable.

 This is why it take a very long time to find 'p (g g g 1)' because all
recursive calls are replaced with a 'begin ... ensure'

C> ##########################
C> p ([1,3,3,[3,4],"a"] == [1,3,3,[3,4],"a"]) 
C> p ([1,3,3,[3,4],"a"] == [1,3,3,[3,4],"b"])

C> ##########################
C> a =[1,2,3]; a << a; b =[1,2]; b << b;  a  << a; b << a; 
C> p a - b; p a; p b

 In this case it give the good result

pigeon% cat b.rb
#!./ruby
p ([1,3,3,[3,4],"a"] == [1,3,3,[3,4],"a"]) 
p ([1,3,3,[3,4],"a"] == [1,3,3,[3,4],"b"])
 
a =[1,2,3]; a << a; b =[1,2]; b << b;  a  << a; b << a; 
p a - b; p a; p b
pigeon% 

pigeon% b.rb
true
false
[3]
[1, 2, 3, [...], [...]]
[1, 2, [...], [1, 2, 3, [...], [...]]]
pigeon% 


C> ##########################
C> def f(x); [x,x]; end
C> def g(x); f f f f f f f f x; end
C> def h(x); g g g g g g g g x; end
C> def i(x);  h h h h h h h h x; end
C> def j(x); i i i i  i i i   x;end

C> p (j(1) == j(1))

 Here it take too long time to compute it.


Guy Decoux