From: Johan Gustav Date: 2010-10-08T22:21:37+09:00 Subject: Re: isolate 2.0.1 Released Thomas Sawyer wrote: > On May 24, 7:15�pm, John Barnette wrote: >> isolate version 2.0.1 has been released! >> >> * >> >> Isolate is a very simple RubyGems sandbox. It provides a way to >> express and automatically install your project's Gem dependencies. > > An interesting project, I think, in light to Bundler. Basically it > seems like you refined the idea of Bundler down to it's essential > usage as an "isolator", and got rid of the other features. The one > exception perhaps being dependency resolution. But I like your "Not > Gonna Happen" takes: > > * Dependency resolution. If this ever becomes a serious problem > for us, we�ll likely push hard to solve it in RubyGems proper. If you > run into these sorts of problems a lot, use Bundler. Or less > libraries. > * Autorequire. Unlike config.gems or other solutions, Isolate > expects you to be a good little Rubyist and manually require the > libraries you use. > * Support for Git or other SCMs. You�re welcome to write an > extension that supports �em, but Isolate itself is focused on > packaged, released gems. > > I have to agree. RubyGems proper should probably be in charge of > dependency resolution. The autorequire feature of RubyGems itself has > always been a bad idea (IMO). And really, doesn't one our SCMs provide > tools for vendoring? Why would Bundler need to do it? > > The one thing that strikes me though. Your Isolate file format is so > close to Bundler's Gemfile, I'm not sure there's any reason to name it > something else. All you have to do is support `group` as another term > for `env` and then Isolate's file should be a full subset of Gemfile. > You might even make isolate handle unused aspects of Bundler's > Gemfile's spec gracefully, then anyone can use Isolate who also uses > Bundler. Hi, I have not been using rails for quite some time (Rails3 was still beta back then). I did not have any problems with rails but bundler gave me all this strange error messages and now I feel a bit uncomfortable about start using it again. My question is if bundler matured much during the last 4-6 month and if Isolate are still being developed as an alternative. Should be interested in your experiences if you used them both. (don't know if this is the right place to post this) thanks I don't know if this is the right place to ask -- Posted via http://www.ruby-forum.com/.