Re: rdoc/xml questions

Dave Thomas wrote:

>    how should the corresponding XML be generated in terms of
>    nesting. Logically, you might want to see

I'd prefer nesting.  With the other way, you won't be able to as easily 
extract information you may want.

One reason why I wrote api2xml was specifically for the XML.  I never got 
around to writing the utility, but I had envisioned an 'ri'-like tool where 
you could ask "what are the classes that extend A?"  You /could/ perform 
this sort of XPath query on your non-nested example, but it would be much 
more difficult.

> 2. For hyperlinking between things, should I use my own tags, or are there
>    benefits to using xlink/xpointer?

That's easy: XLink.

1) XLink and XPointer are well defined and not complex.
2) When direct XML support in applications gets better, you'll be able to 
benefit directly from it, rather than /having/ to use some transformation 
to get the links into something you can use.
3) My guess is that there isn't any significant cost savings in rolling your 
own.
4) You'll become more familiar with the standard, thus increasing your skill 
set and making you more markettable!  Wahoo!

--- SER