From: Phrogz Date: 2007-08-09T02:29:59+09:00 Subject: Re: Revised RCR Process (was Re: #send in 1.9) On Aug 8, 11:17 am, "Robert Dober" wrote: > On 8/8/07, Trans wrote: > > That is what I have been suggesting for years now -- a dedicated > > mailing list and a wiki for the community to jointly develop RCRs on. > > It also wouldn't hurt if there were some sort of stated protocols, > > about what happens if an RCR gets substantial support by the > > community. > I guess UR right a Wiki would just do great :) > That at least I have learned from this discussion ... > Robert Interesting - I disagree. I very much like the idea of a single champion with his/her own personal vision for an RCR. I'd not like to put forth a well-thought-out design, and have some random chump come in and decide that he personally thinks it should be different and migrate my RCR to something different. Sure, I could vigilantly watch my page and fight with the misguided fool in version control, but that would turn me off more than the current system. I like the idea of a single mailing list. I like the idea of a single discussion thread (nested or not) per RCR, where modifications to the proposal may be suggested. I don't like the idea of letting everyone put their grubby little hands all over my spec. :)