[ruby-core:54637] Re: [CommonRuby - Feature #8257][Open] Exception#cause to carry originating exception along with new one

On Sat, Apr 27, 2013 at 5:19 PM, SASADA Koichi <[e-mail]> wrote:
> (1) introduce new keyword?
>
>  example: raise(..., cause: e)

Yeah, that's not bad. Keywords allow us to avoid changing the
signature in new/incompatible/non-forward-compatible ways.

> (2) How about to use `$!' forcibly?

Do you mean automatically stick $! into Exception#cause when creating
(or perhaps better, when raising) a new Exception? That's not a bad
idea.

Interestingly, java.lang.Throwable also does not allow setting the
cause. You can set it during init or after init *at most once*. Here's
JavaDoc for it:
http://docs.oracle.com/javase/7/docs/api/java/lang/Throwable.html#initCause(java.lang.Throwable)

I quote: "This method can be called at most once. It is generally
called from within the constructor, or immediately after creating the
throwable. If this throwable was created with Throwable(Throwable) or
Throwable(String,Throwable), this method cannot be called even once."

Java 7 also added an additional mechanism for attaching exceptions,
called "supressed exceptions".
http://docs.oracle.com/javase/7/docs/api/java/lang/Throwable.html#addSuppressed(java.lang.Throwable)

This mechanism was added for exceptions that are not really the
*cause*, but which are related. For example, an IO read operation
raises an error, and while handling that error and attempting to close
the stream a second error is raised. The read error did not cause the
close error, but you don't want to lose either. You raise the close
error with the read error attached as "suppressed".

I think for purposes of this feature, adding cause, which can be
initialized during construction only, would be sufficient. I have no
strong opinion about automatically using $! as the cause, but it might
be nice.