From: SASADA Koichi <ko1@...>
Date: 2011-10-02T16:09:15+09:00
Subject: [ruby-core:39823] Discussion results

Hi,

We made a discuss tonight, the last day of RubyConf 2011 about 2.0
features and several conclusion.

I send a memo of discussion.  I hope it will boost a process toward 2.0.


* Module#prepend and Module#mix

- Module#mix => rejected
- Module#prepend

# Sorry, I can't write the discussion why we decide this specification.

  class C0;
    def foo; :C0; end
  end

  module M
    def foo; :m; end
  end

  class C1 < C0
    prepend M
    def foo; :C1; end
  end

  C.ancestors #=> [M, C1, C0, Object]
  C.new.foo

  C1.new.foo #=> :m
  C1.remove_method(:foo)
  C1.new.foo #=> :m
  C1.new.foo #=> C0

* Allow duplication in same module in ancestor tree

  module M0; end
  module M1; include M0; end
  module M2; prepend M0; end

  class C
    include M0
    prepend M1
    include M2
    prepend M0
  end

  # Mx@My means Mx module included/prepended by My
  C.ancestors #=> [M0, M1, M0@M1, C, M0@M2, M2, M0, Object]

* Object#confirm_to?([an array of symbols])

It is same as:
  [an array of symbols].all?{|sym|
    obj.respond_to? sym
  }

* %s(foo bar) or %S(foo bar) notation

Same as [:foo, :bar].  %s and %S is same as %w and %W?

* Method#source_location

Return also begin and end position in file.  You can get source code
using it.  We don't decide how to return this location.

  def m; end
  p method(:m).source_location
    #=> [file, line, beg, end]
    # or
    #=> [file, line, (beg .. end)]
    # or others?

* Float literal (1.0 or 3.2 or something) should return Rational object
or not?

  ex) 1.3 #=> Rational(3, 10)
      1/2 #=> 0 (not changed integer division)
      1/2.0 #=> Rational
      1.fdiv(2) #=> 0.5

Matz like this idea.  But it has compatibility issue?

(not concluded)

* nonblocking I/O

not concluded.

- Exception (EEOF etc) is too heavy for Rails app.
- We need more lightweight exception object creation.

* Threading (remove GVL or GIL)

We don't remove GVL on 2.0.


-- 
// SASADA Koichi at atdot dot net