[ruby-core:31452] Re: [Feature #3595] Theres no encoding to differentiate a stream of Binary data from an 8-Bit ASCII string

On Jul 22, 2010, at 12:42 PM, Roger Pack wrote:

> I think his original complaint was that if he's passing back data from a method, like
> 
> def give_me_your_binary_data
> end
> 
> The *can't* pass back a string that is marked as BINARY encoding, since querying for its encoding returns "ASCII-8BIT".
> 
> See the previous discussion (which I think never quite terminated--any more thoughts there?)
> Maybe it should be renamed as its default GENERIC and have ASCII-8BIT as an alias.
> Thoughts?

If this is the case, then I feel we're arguing semantics. There is no such thing as an "ASCII-8BIT" string (where by "string" I mean an array of characters that can be printed). Values 129-256 in an "ASCII-8BIT" string cannot be printed or converted to any other encoding. Personally, I'd be in favor of making "BINARY" the default and "ASCII-8BIT" the alias, but it shouldn't matter.

- Josh